Underwriting guidelines are an insurer’s written rules for which risks it will accept, which it will refer to a senior underwriter, and which it will decline, along with the terms it offers. They turn the carrier’s appetite into decisions that an underwriter, or a system, can apply the same way to every submission.
What underwriting guidelines contain
| Part | What it sets | Illustrative example |
|---|---|---|
| Eligibility | The risks the carrier will write at all | No vacant buildings; no fireworks manufacturers. |
| Referral triggers | What a senior underwriter must approve | Values above the underwriter’s authority; a roof past a set age; recent large losses. |
| Location rules | Where the carrier will and will not add exposure | No new business within a set distance of the coast, or above a wildfire score threshold. |
| Terms and conditions | What changes with the risk | A higher wind or hail deductible near the coast. |
| Information required | What a complete submission must include | Photos, roof age, alarm certificates, a statement of values, five years of loss history. |
| Authority | Who can bind what | Binding authority by value, line and class for each underwriter and agent. |
Examples for property insurance
Every carrier sets its own thresholds; the rules below show the kind of statement a property guideline contains.
- Refer any home with a roof older than a set age, or with an unknown roof age.
- Decline frame buildings beyond a set distance from a responding fire station.
- Decline commercial occupancies outside appetite, identified by NAICS code.
- Apply a percentage hurricane deductible within a set distance of the coast.
- Refer any location where the carrier’s insured value within a set radius already exceeds its accumulation limit.
- Hold new business inside an area under moratorium until it is lifted.
Wildfire underwriting guidelines
Wildfire guidelines usually combine a score for the location with what has been done at the property:
- A wildfire risk score threshold above which new business is referred or declined.
- Defensible space: vegetation cleared or managed for a set distance around the building.
- Ember-resistant construction, such as a noncombustible roof covering, ember-resistant vents and enclosed eaves.
- Access for fire engines, and distance to a responding station and water supply.
- A moratorium on new business near an active fire.
A threshold is only as good as the score behind it. A score that rates a whole ZIP code at once, or that rests on two to four variables, either blocks insurable homes or lets dangerous ones through. How a wildfire risk score works covers what to look for.
Commercial property underwriting guidelines
Commercial guidelines are usually organized by class of business, because occupancy drives most of the risk. For each class they set eligibility, the COPE standards a risk must meet, and the questions and documents a submission must include.
UrbanStat’s industry risk guides give, for 747 business types by NAICS and SIC code, typical ratings on twelve lines, the questions to ask, the documents to request and the red flags that call for referral: a starting point for writing class guidelines, or for checking a submission against them.
Questions underwriters ask
Underwriting questions exist to test a submission against the guidelines. For a home they usually cover:
- Year built, construction and floor area.
- Roof covering, age and condition.
- Heating, wiring and plumbing, and when each was last updated.
- Occupancy: owner-occupied, rented, vacant or seasonal, and any business run from the premises.
- Protection: alarms, sprinklers, and distance to a fire station and hydrant.
- Hazards on the premises, such as a pool, a trampoline or a wood stove.
- Losses in the last three to five years.
Many of the property answers can be filled from data before the applicant is asked, which shortens the application and catches answers that do not match. Commercial questions depend on the business; each industry risk guide lists them for its business type.
Enforcing guidelines consistently
Guidelines kept in a manual are applied unevenly: two underwriters read the same rule differently, and location rules are hard to check by eye. Turning them into rules that run on every submission removes that. In UrbanStat, location rules and moratoriums are drawn as polygons on the map, enforced in real time through the Risk Analysis API on new business and renewals, and kept with a full audit trail; see Moratorium Management.
Common questions
What are underwriting guidelines in insurance?
An insurer’s written rules for which risks it will accept, refer or decline, and on what terms. They put the carrier’s appetite into a form underwriters and systems can apply the same way to every submission.
What is the difference between underwriting guidelines and appetite?
Appetite is what the carrier wants to write. Guidelines are the rules that put it into practice, including what it will not write and what needs referral.
What is a referral in underwriting?
A submission sent to a more senior underwriter, or to the carrier, because it falls outside the reviewer’s authority or trips a guideline, such as a value above a limit or a roof past a set age.
What questions do underwriters ask?
Questions that test the submission against the guidelines. For a home: construction, roof, updates, occupancy, protection, hazards and loss history. For a business, also what it does, how and where. The industry risk guides list them by business type.
How often should underwriting guidelines be reviewed?
Whenever results or exposure change, and at least once a year. Location rules need the most attention, because hazards, building values and the carrier’s own accumulation keep moving.